MF

Matthew Fornaro

Business Litigation Attorney · Coral Springs, FL

Matthew Fornaro is a Florida business law attorney serving Coral Springs, Parkland, and Broward County. He represents small businesses in commercial litigation, contract disputes, and business torts. Schedule a consultation →

Key Takeaways

  • Florida business law protects companies from unfair competition, contract breaches, and partner disputes.
  • Acting early saves time, money, and business relationships.
  • An experienced business attorney helps you assess risk and choose the right legal strategy.

A Florida business interruption claim pays you for lost income and continuing expenses while a covered physical loss keeps you closed. It works only if the policy language, your records and the deadlines all line up. Most disputes over these claims come down to three things: whether the loss is covered at all, how the lost income is calculated, and whether you gave notice and filed proof on time. If your insurer delays, underpays or denies, that is a contract dispute, and it is the point where a business litigation lawyer earns the fee.

Fornarolegal
Address a Business Insurance Dispute
Fornarolegal represents South Florida businesses in disputes, including disagreements over insurance claims, contracts and business operations.

Visit

TL;DR

  • Business interruption (BI) coverage is optional in Florida, and it generally requires direct physical damage to insured property. Florida’s CFO consumer FAQ says so plainly.
  • Typical exclusions include flooding, earthquakes, pandemics and utility outages. Check your policy’s wording and any endorsements before you file.
  • Notice of a property claim is due within 1 year after the date of loss, and a supplemental claim within 18 months, under Fla. Stat. 627.70132. Your policy may set shorter internal deadlines, such as proof of loss.
  • The “90-day rule” you may have heard about applies to condo loss assessments, not to business interruption claims.
  • If the claim is underpaid or denied, read the policy’s dispute provisions first. Appraisal, arbitration and a suit-limitation clause can all change your options.

Table of Contents

What a business interruption claim is

Business interruption insurance replaces income your business loses when a covered event damages your property and you cannot operate normally. The Florida CFO’s guide for small businesses frames the question this way: if damage forces you to close temporarily, can you still pay your lease, loan payments, salaries and taxes until you reopen?

The NAIC, the national association of state insurance regulators, draws the line clearly. Commercial property coverage pays for the physical damage. Business interruption coverage pays for lost net income while the business is closed for repairs. They are two different payments, and you usually claim them together.

Three points shape everything that follows:

  1. It is not mandatory. The Florida CFO’s FAQ says BI coverage is not required by Florida law. Whether you have it depends on the policy forms your insurer filed with the state’s Office of Insurance Regulation (OIR) and on what you bought, typically within a Business Owners Policy or a Commercial Package Policy.
  2. It needs physical damage. Income loss generally is not covered without direct physical damage to insured property.
  3. The wording controls. If your policy excludes wind, the BI coverage is typically endorsed to exclude wind-caused losses too.

If you are still deciding what coverage a young company should carry, our guide to Florida business insurance requirements for startups is the place to start.

When you can claim

The American Bar Association’s claim checklist describes a typical BI claim as having these elements:

  • Physical loss or damage to insured property.
  • A covered cause of loss.
  • An actual interruption of your business.
  • A defined restoration period during which you lose income.

A South Florida example: a storm tears the roof off your Coral Springs retail unit, and rain ruins the interior. The unit cannot open for eight weeks. Your property coverage pays for the building and contents, subject to its terms. Your BI coverage addresses the net income you would have earned and the expenses that continue, such as payroll and rent.

Now change one fact. The neighboring plaza loses power, and your shop is undamaged but dark. The CFO’s guide lists loss of electricity, gas or water among the typical exclusions. The difference between the two scenarios is physical damage from a covered event, and insurers look hard at that point.

What is usually covered, and what is usually not

The Florida CFO’s FAQ and its Business Interruption Coverage guide describe typical coverage. Read your own policy against this list.

Item Typically treated as
Lost income while closed Covered, if the cause of loss is covered
Continuing expenses such as employee wages Covered, per the CFO FAQ
Extra Expense (temporary location, rented equipment, overtime) Covered if you bought it, per the CFO guide
Flooding and earthquakes Generally excluded unless endorsed or insured separately
Pandemics, viruses, communicable disease Generally excluded
Loss of electricity, gas or water Typically excluded
Undocumented income Typically excluded
Partial closure where you can still operate Typically excluded
Food spoilage Generally not covered unless specifically purchased

Two more details matter in practice.

Duration. The CFO guide says BI coverage is typically provided for 30 days, though insurers may offer coverage up to 12 months. A long rebuild after a hurricane can outlast a 30-day limit, so check this number before you need it.

Extra Expense. This coverage pays the costs of getting back up and running: renting a temporary location, leasing equipment or computers, paying overtime or hiring additional help. Keep every receipt. These costs are often the easiest to document and the easiest to lose through sloppy record-keeping.

Records that support the claim

A BI claim is a financial calculation, and the insurer will ask you to prove each input. The ABA checklist advises documenting your loss-mitigation efforts and expenses as well as the loss itself. Build a file with:

  • Profit and loss statements and tax returns for the periods before the loss.
  • Monthly sales records, so a seasonal pattern is visible. A Fort Lauderdale restaurant that earns a large share of its revenue in the winter months needs the insurer to see that.
  • Payroll records for the closure period.
  • Lease, loan and utility statements for expenses that continued.
  • Receipts for everything you spent to reduce the loss: temporary space, rentals, overtime.
  • Photos and video of the damage, dated as early as possible.
  • A log of every call, email and inspection with the insurer.

Undocumented income is on the CFO’s list of typical exclusions. If your books are thin, fix that now, before a loss.

Deadlines: the part that sinks claims

The ABA checklist makes a blunt point: missing policy deadlines can forfeit coverage regardless of the claim’s merits. It recommends building a timeline on day one.

Statutory notice deadlines

Under Fla. Stat. 627.70132, a claim or reopened claim under a property insurance policy is barred unless you notify the insurer within 1 year after the date of loss. A supplemental claim, for additional loss from the same peril under an open claim, is barred unless noticed within 18 months. The OIR’s 2023 informational memorandum explains that Senate Bill 2-A, signed December 16, 2022, shortened these from two years and three years. Old advice you find online may use the longer periods.

The same statute says it does not affect the civil-action time limits in section 95.11 for claims that were timely filed. Notice and lawsuit deadlines are separate clocks.

Policy deadlines

Your policy adds its own requirements: prompt notice, a signed and sworn proof of loss, and sometimes a suit-limitation period. The ABA checklist notes that some policies require proof of loss as soon as 60 days after the event. A proof of loss is a formal statement, signed by you and notarized, giving the amount of loss, supporting documents, the date and cause of loss and the interested parties. If a deadline is close and you need more time, ask the insurer in writing for an extension.

What the 90-day rule actually is

People searching this topic often ask about a “90-day rule.” In the statute, the 90-day period appears only in the notice rule for condominium loss assessment coverage, where notice runs from the association’s vote to levy an assessment. It is not a business interruption deadline. Do not rely on it.

Insurer timelines

The OIR memorandum describes insurer duties under SB 2-A for personal and commercial residential property insurers. They must acknowledge claims within 7 days, begin investigating within 7 days after receiving proof of loss, inspect within 30 days, and pay or deny within 60 days unless factors beyond their control cause delay. Those deadlines are tolled, meaning paused, during mediation and when the insurer asks for material information and you do not provide it within 10 days. The memo also says insurers may void a policy where false or misleading claim information is given with intent to defraud. Whether these particular timelines apply to your commercial policy depends on the policy type, so confirm that before you count days.

Insurer claim response deadlines and tolling periods

How to submit and follow up

Here is the process from the first day, with the point at which each step usually goes wrong.

  1. Protect the property and limit the loss. Take reasonable steps to prevent further damage and keep receipts. The ABA checklist treats loss mitigation as a requirement. Claims go wrong when owners wait for the adjuster before acting and the damage grows.
  2. Give written notice quickly. Send it to the insurer, and keep proof of delivery. Do not rely on a phone call.
  3. Photograph and document everything. Insurers may investigate electronically, with photographs, video, recorded video conferences and drone footage, per the OIR memo. Your own record should be as complete as theirs.
  4. Read the policy’s BI provisions. Find the waiting period, the maximum duration, the coverage limit, Extra Expense, and any exclusions or endorsements.
  5. Assemble the financial package. Use the records above, and keep the calculation consistent with your tax filings.
  6. File a signed, sworn proof of loss in the policy’s required form and time. The ABA checklist says an insurer may reject a proof of loss only for technical reasons, and must identify the deficiencies. Fix them promptly.
  7. Keep a communication log and calendar every deadline.
  8. Be accurate. Overstating a loss is the fastest way to turn a good claim into a fraud defense.

A good claim file is organized before anyone disputes it. If you suspect from the first adjuster visit that the insurer is reading the policy narrowly, that is the time to have counsel review the policy and your submission, not after a denial letter arrives.

When the claim is delayed, underpaid or denied

Denials in BI cases tend to rest on a handful of grounds: no direct physical damage, an excluded cause, a dispute over the amount of lost income, or a missed deadline. Each calls for a different response.

Start with the policy’s dispute provisions. The ABA checklist advises checking for arbitration clauses, appraisal (a process used when coverage is agreed but the amount is disputed), and choice-of-law and choice-of-forum terms. If a suit-limitation deadline is near, consider asking the insurer to extend or toll it, meaning pause it.

Understand how Florida courts read policies. Florida construes insurance contracts by their plain language. The Third District Court of Appeal applied that rule in Opinion 2023-1435, a civil-authority case. The policy covered losses from a government order issued because of a threat at “the premises of the Insured.” The court held the order had to target the insured’s own premises. General shutdown orders aimed at many commercial properties did not trigger coverage. The lesson for a small business is that a few words in a policy can decide a six-figure claim, and the words are read as written.

Respond in writing. If the insurer cites a deficiency, answer it point by point. If it disputes the amount, put your calculation and supporting documents in front of it.

Choose the right forum. Some disputes end in a negotiated payment. Others need mediation, arbitration or a lawsuit. Our article on mediation, arbitration or litigation in a Florida business dispute walks through how to choose. If you are weighing when to bring a lawyer into a dispute generally, what a commercial dispute attorney does covers it.

When the claim is delayed, underpaid or denied

What this article cannot do is tell you whether your particular policy covers your particular loss. That depends on the exact policy language and facts, and a lawyer reading the policy and the denial letter side by side can answer it.

Perspective

Business owners usually come to us after the insurer’s first answer, not before it. The claim was filed, the adjuster visited, and then a letter arrived that reads the policy more narrowly than the owner expected.

What we have learned in more than 20 years of practice is that disputes are won or lost on the same things: the contract language, the paper trail and the calendar. A BI claim is a contract dispute with a number attached. The owner who kept clean financials, sent written notice early and tracked deadlines has options. The owner who relied on phone calls and good faith has fewer.

Our approach is practical. Read the policy first. Work out what the claim is worth and what it will cost to pursue. Then choose the path, whether that is a firm letter, mediation, arbitration or a lawsuit, that gets you the best result for the least disruption to running your business.

If you are a South Florida business owner with a stalled or denied claim, we would rather see it early.

Matthew

How we help South Florida businesses with claim disputes

Our firm represents small businesses, startups and entrepreneurs in South Florida in business disputes, through business litigation, arbitration and mediation. When an insurer’s decision becomes a contract dispute, we can review the situation, advise on the dispute path and represent you in it. Matthew Fornaro has more than 20 years of experience and holds an AV Preeminent rating. If your loss involves a commercial property or a contractor’s work, we also handle real estate litigation and construction litigation.

Fornarolegal

We bill hourly or per matter, depending on scope, so the first conversation can define what the work involves. Reach us through fornarolegal.com.

FAQ

When can you claim business interruption insurance?

You can claim when a covered event physically damages insured property and the damage forces you to suspend or reduce operations. The policy must include BI coverage, and the cause of loss must not be excluded. Give notice to the insurer promptly, and within the statutory period of 1 year after the date of loss.

What is the 90-day rule for insurance claims in Florida?

The 90-day period in Fla. Stat. 627.70132 applies to condominium loss assessment claims, where notice runs from the association’s vote to levy an assessment. It does not govern business interruption claims. For those, the statute sets 1 year for notice of a new or reopened claim and 18 months for a supplemental claim, and your policy may add shorter requirements.

Does business interruption insurance cover a pandemic or a flood?

Generally no. The Florida CFO’s guidance lists flooding, earthquakes, and pandemics or viruses among typical exclusions, though coverage for some may be added by endorsement or a separate policy. Check your policy and any endorsements for the exact wording.

How long does business interruption coverage last?

The Florida CFO’s guide says BI coverage is typically provided for 30 days, though insurers may offer up to 12 months. Your policy’s declarations page states the period and the limit you actually bought.

What should I do if my claim is denied or underpaid?

Read the denial against the policy, check its appraisal, arbitration and suit-limitation provisions, and respond in writing to any stated deficiency. Keep every deadline on a calendar. If the dispute is about coverage or a large amount, have a business litigation lawyer review the policy and the file.

Sources

Facing a business dispute in Florida?

Get a straight answer from an attorney who understands small business.

Schedule a consultation