Sued or Threatened With a Lawsuit? Call Your Insurance Carrier Before You Call Anyone Else
Key Takeaways
- Florida business law protects companies from unfair competition, contract breaches, and partner disputes.
- Acting early saves time, money, and business relationships.
- An experienced business attorney helps you assess risk and choose the right legal strategy.
By Matthew Fornaro, Esq. | Business Litigation Attorney · Coral Springs, FL
Key Takeaways
- Notice is not optional. Nearly every liability, professional, property, auto, bond, and indemnity-type policy requires prompt written notice of a claim, a lawsuit, or even circumstances that could become one.
- Report it even if you think it isn’t covered. Whether coverage exists is the insurer’s call to make after it reads the policy and the complaint, not yours to make in advance.
- Late notice can cost you coverage you paid for. A carrier that never hears about a lawsuit until after a default or a settlement demand has real arguments to deny it.
- This is not just a defendant’s issue. Property damage, construction defects, employee theft, and other losses may be covered under your own policies or someone else’s, and a potential plaintiff should check before filing.
- Call your broker and your attorney together. Each one catches things the other might miss.
Table of Contents
- The Question I Ask Every Client First
- Why Business Owners Hesitate to Notify Their Insurer
- What Is the Point of Insurance If You Never Use It?
- Which Policies Can Respond to a Lawsuit or Dispute
- What Late Notice Can Cost You
- Insurance Isn’t Only for Defendants
- What to Do in the First 72 Hours
- What Happens After You Notify: Defense, Reservation of Rights, or Denial
- Frequently Asked Questions
The Question I Ask Every Client First
When a business owner calls me because they have been served with a lawsuit, received a demand letter, been named as a respondent in an arbitration, or are weighing whether to sue someone, I ask one question before almost anything else:
“Have you notified your insurance company?”
Most of my practice is commercial litigation and breach of contract disputes. I am not a personal injury lawyer and I am not an insurance defense lawyer. Yet insurance comes up in my cases constantly, and the answer I hear most often is some version of, “No. I didn’t think of it.”
That answer worries me. The owner has already spent time and money on a policy, sometimes for years, and has not once asked whether it applies to the dispute now sitting on the kitchen table or the conference room desk.
If you take only one thing from this article, take this: when you are sued, threatened with suit, or about to sue, checking your insurance is not a later step. It is one of the first.
Why Business Owners Hesitate to Notify Their Insurer
I understand the hesitation. In my experience it usually comes from one of four places:
- Fear of higher premiums. “If I report this, my rates will go up.”
- Assuming it won’t be covered. “This is a contract dispute, so insurance doesn’t apply.”
- Reaching for a lawyer by reflex. “I just need an attorney.” You do, but an attorney is not a substitute for notice to a carrier.
- Not knowing which policy to look at. Many owners cannot say offhand what they have, or who their broker is.
Each of these is understandable. Each can also become expensive, because the policy usually does not leave the decision to notify up to you. It makes prompt notice a condition of coverage.
Watch Out
The question is rarely “Will my insurer pay?” in the first week. The question is “Will I have preserved my right to ask?” Do not trade a possible defense benefit for a worry about next year’s renewal.
What Is the Point of Insurance If You Never Use It?
I put it to my clients this way, and I mean it kindly: you have been paying for protection. A lawsuit is exactly what that protection exists for. If you have a policy that may respond to a claim against you, or to a loss you suffered, when would you plan to use it?
Sometimes the carrier picks up the defense. Sometimes it picks up part of it, under a reservation of rights. Sometimes it declines. I tell my clients that I cannot predict which, and neither can they. That is exactly why you tender the claim and let the insurer put its position in writing.
What I can say is that I have watched a defense paid by a carrier change the entire economics of a case for a small business. I have also seen the opposite: owners who waited, hoped, and only then called the carrier, with the file already complicated by missed deadlines or discussions that should have involved the insurer.
Which Policies Can Respond to a Lawsuit or Dispute
Business owners often think of one policy, typically general liability, and stop there. Over the years I have found that many more policies deserve a look, depending on the facts of the dispute:
| Type of coverage | Examples of when it may be worth a look |
|---|---|
| Commercial general liability (CGL) | Claims alleging property damage, bodily injury, or certain “personal and advertising injury” |
| Professional liability / errors & omissions | Claims that your professional services were negligent or fell short |
| Directors & officers (D&O) | Claims against company leadership, partner or shareholder disputes |
| Employment practices liability (EPLI) | Wrongful termination, discrimination, or harassment claims |
| Commercial auto / hired and non-owned auto | Accidents involving company vehicles or employees on the job |
| Commercial property / builder’s risk | Fire, water, storm, or construction-related physical loss or damage |
| Cyber liability | Data breaches, ransomware, and related third-party claims |
| Umbrella or excess | Claims that exceed the limits of your primary policy |
| Surety, performance, and payment bonds | Contractor defaults, unpaid subs and suppliers, project failures |
| Fidelity / crime coverage | Employee theft or fraud |
| Contractual indemnity and additional insured status | Claims where another party agreed in a contract to indemnify you or name you on their policy |
That last row matters, especially in construction and vendor relationships. A subcontractor’s insurer may owe you a defense as an additional insured, but only if someone tenders the claim. In my line of work I look for those rights early, because they are easy to overlook and hard to rebuild after the fact.
Pro Tip
Pull every policy that was in force when the underlying event happened, not just the one currently in effect. Coverage often turns on when an event occurred or when a claim was first made, depending on whether the policy is occurrence-based or claims-made.
What Late Notice Can Cost You
This is the part of the conversation where I get most serious, because it is the part that is easy to prevent and hard to fix.
Notice is a condition of the policy. Most policies require you to notify the insurer “as soon as practicable” or “promptly” of a claim or suit, and to forward suit papers immediately. Some policies are claims-made, which means the claim must be reported within the policy period or a short extended reporting window. Miss it, and coverage may be gone, regardless of how strong your underlying defense is.
Florida courts look at prejudice. In general, when an insured gives late notice under an occurrence policy, Florida law presumes the insurer was prejudiced, and the insured may try to rebut that presumption. That is not a comfortable position to start from. Why begin with an uphill argument when a phone call or an email to your broker would have avoided it?
The clock is shorter than you think. A lawsuit in Florida circuit court generally requires a response within 20 days after service. An insurer needs time to review the policy, evaluate the complaint, and appoint defense counsel. If you wait until day 18 to notify the carrier, you have made everyone’s job harder, including mine.
Defaults and early settlements create problems. Many policies include a “voluntary payments” or “no admission” condition. If you pay, settle, or agree to something before the insurer has had a chance to weigh in, you may jeopardize coverage for the very amount you hoped to resolve.
It can affect the relationship and your renewals. Policies also ask questions at renewal about known claims and circumstances. A suit that you knew about but never reported can create trouble, from a denial to a dispute about whether an application was complete and accurate. I cannot tell you what any particular insurer will do, but I can tell you that silence is rarely the safer path.
Watch Out
Many owners are afraid that reporting a claim will raise their rates. In practice, the greater danger can be not reporting: coverage disputes, a denied defense, or a carrier that learns about the suit for the first time from a plaintiff’s lawyer. Ask your broker how reports are handled, but do not skip notice to find out.
Insurance Isn’t Only for Defendants
Everything above applies equally when you are the one considering a lawsuit. I regularly speak with business owners who have suffered a property loss from a construction problem, a contractor’s work, a storm, or a vendor’s failure. They are ready to hire a lawyer and sue. First, I ask:
- Did you report the loss to your own property or builder’s risk carrier?
- Did the party who damaged your property have liability insurance, and has anyone put that carrier on notice?
- Is there a bond (payment or performance) that could respond if a contractor defaulted or failed to pay?
- Does a crime or fidelity policy cover the employee theft you discovered last week?
- Is there a contractual indemnity or additional insured right you can invoke?
Property claims in particular carry statutory notice deadlines in Florida, and they are shorter than many owners expect. Generally, a new property insurance claim must be reported within one year of the date of loss. Bond claims often carry strict notice windows of their own. A good claim that was reported late can become a bad one.
Florida also gives injured parties a tool of their own: under Section 627.4137, Florida Statutes, an insurer that may provide liability coverage must disclose policy information, including the limits, within 30 days of a written request from a claimant. Insurance is often part of how disputes get resolved, whether or not you are the one who is covered.
What to Do in the First 72 Hours
When a demand letter arrives or you are served, here is the order I recommend. It is practical, not complicated.
- Do not ignore, panic, or reply in anger. Read the document. Note the date and method of service. Calendar every deadline.
- Call your insurance broker or agent the same day. Tell them you have received a claim or a lawsuit, and ask them to confirm which of your policies may be implicated. Your broker knows what you bought.
- Give written notice to every potentially responsive carrier. Do not stop at one. Send the notice in the manner the policy requires, include the demand or suit papers, and keep proof of delivery. When in doubt, notify more policies, not fewer.
- Alert your advisors. That means your attorney, but also your CPA, your risk manager, and anyone else whose advice may bear on the dispute or its financial effects.
- Preserve everything. Emails, texts, contracts, change orders, photos, invoices, and project files. Do not delete anything, even if it is unflattering.
- Hold off on payments, admissions, and settlements. Do not agree to anything with the other side until you have checked how your policy treats it.
- Ask the insurer for its coverage position in writing. Then forward every letter it sends to your attorney promptly. Coverage letters have deadlines and technical language that matter.
- Be accurate and consistent. What you tell your insurer, your attorney, and the other side should line up. Your attorney can help you present the facts clearly.
Pro Tip
Tell your broker and your attorney at the same time. Your broker knows the policies. Your attorney knows how the claim will be framed in the complaint, which matters because a liability insurer’s duty to defend in Florida is generally measured by the allegations of the complaint, not by what you believe the real story is.
What Happens After You Notify: Defense, Reservation of Rights, or Denial
Once you give notice, one of three things typically happens.
The carrier accepts the defense. It appoints counsel and pays defense costs, subject to the policy’s limits and terms. That is often the best-case outcome.
The carrier defends under a reservation of rights. It agrees to defend while reserving the right to contest coverage later. Under Section 627.426, Florida Statutes, a liability insurer that wants to rely on a coverage defense generally must give written notice of its reservation of rights within 30 days of when it knew or should have known of the defense, and take other steps, such as obtaining a non-waiver agreement or retaining independent counsel, within the statutory timeframe. These letters are technical. Please do not file one away unread.
The carrier denies or declines. That is not necessarily the end of the discussion. A denial can be reviewed against the policy language and the allegations of the complaint, and coverage positions sometimes change when additional facts or policies come to light. Many disputes I handle involve more than one policy, and a denial from one carrier does not answer the question for the others.
In every scenario, you are better off having made the notification and received an answer than having stayed quiet. And remember: even when a carrier declines coverage, the policy may still have required you to tell it about the suit. Giving notice protects your position either way.
The Bottom Line: Take It Seriously, and Start With the Policy
Litigation is stressful, and the instinct to find a lawyer right away is a good one. I just ask business owners to pair it with a second instinct: find your policies and notify your carriers.
Your insurance is not a trophy to keep on the shelf. It is a business tool you paid for. Used promptly and correctly, it can change who pays for the defense, how a settlement is funded, and how much risk lands on your company’s balance sheet.
If you have received a demand letter, been served, or are weighing a lawsuit over a contract, construction, or property issue, I would be glad to help you map out your options, including whether insurance, a bond, or an indemnity right is in the picture. At Fornaro Legal, I help small businesses, founders, and entrepreneurs throughout Coral Springs, Parkland, Broward County, and South Florida understand their options and make business-first decisions.
Facing a business dispute in Florida? Schedule a consultation or call 954-324-3651.
Frequently Asked Questions
Do I have to notify my insurance company if I’m sued, even if I think the claim isn’t covered?
In most cases, yes, you should. Many policies require prompt notice of any claim or suit, and coverage questions are decided after the insurer reviews the policy and the complaint. Skipping notice can forfeit coverage that might have applied.
Will my premiums go up if I report a lawsuit to my insurer?
It depends on the insurer, the policy, and the claim, and I cannot predict it. Your broker can explain how reports are handled. But failing to report can create larger problems than a premium change, including denied coverage.
What is a “tender of defense”?
A tender of defense is a formal written request that an insurer, or another party with a contractual obligation such as an indemnitor, take over and pay for your defense of a claim.
What is a reservation of rights letter?
It is a letter from the insurer saying it will provide a defense (or investigate) while preserving its right to deny coverage later. Florida has statutory requirements for these notices in liability coverage, so review it with your attorney.
What if I’m the one who wants to sue? Should I still check my insurance?
Yes. Property damage, construction defects, employee theft, and contractor defaults may implicate your own policies, the other party’s liability coverage, or a bond. Notice deadlines can apply to you as well.
Does insurance apply to arbitration, not just lawsuits?
It can, depending on the policy’s definition of “suit” or “claim” and its consent requirements. Notify the carrier of an arbitration demand the same way you would a complaint, and have your attorney review the policy language.
Should I contact a lawyer or my insurance company first?
Do both right away. Your insurance broker knows what you bought; your attorney knows how to protect your position in the dispute and read the policy against the claim.
General information only; not legal advice. Reading this article does not create an attorney-client relationship. Insurance coverage depends on the specific policy language and facts, and notice deadlines vary by policy and statute. Consult an attorney about your particular situation.
Related reading from Fornaro Legal:



